Grimsby Town v Oldham Athletic, 03 September 1996
| Score | 0-1 :: penalties 5-4 to Oldham Athletic |
| Competition | League Cup 1st round 2nd leg |
| Venue | Blundell Park |
| Attendance | 2,371 |
View Grimsby Town v Oldham Athletic head to head
Oldham Athletic won 5-4 on penalties.
1-1 on aggregate.
After extra time.