Everton v Sunderland, 11 November 1998
| Score | 1-1 :: penalties 5-4 to Sunderland |
| Referee | Mike Reed |
| Competition | League Cup 4th round |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 28,132 |
View Everton v Sunderland head to head
Sunderland won 5-4 on penalties.
After extra time - 1-1 at 90 minutes.
1 (4) Everton
Goals:
| John Collins | 74 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Thomas Myhre
Defender
Richard Dunne
Defender
Marco Materazzi
Defender/Centre back
Craig Short
Defender/Midfielder
Michael Ball
Midfielder
John Collins
Midfielder
Olivier Dacourt
Midfielder
Don Hutchison
Midfielder/Forward
Danny Cadamarteri
Forward
Ibrahima Bakayoko
Forward
Duncan Ferguson
Substitutions:
| Alex Cleland for Olivier Dacourt | 46 |
| Tony Grant for Danny Cadamarteri | 66 |
| John Oster for Don Hutchison | 66 |
Cards:
| Richard Dunne | Y | |
| Marco Materazzi | Y |
1 (5) Sunderland
Goals:
| Michael Bridges | 29 |
|
Starting lineup:
Thomas Sørensen
Goalkeeper
Chris Makin
Defender
Andy Melville
Defender
Martin Scott
Defender
Paul Butler
Defender/Centre back
Darren Williams
Defender/Midfielder
Allan Johnston
Midfielder
Paul Thirlwell
Midfielder
Michael Bridges
Forward
Niall Quinn
Forward
Martin Smith
Forward
Substitutions:
| Jody Craddock for Paul Butler | 48 |
| Michael Proctor for Michael Bridges | 61 |
| Lee Clark for Paul Thirlwell | 73 |
Cards:
| Darren Williams | Y |