Everton v Newcastle United, 22 February 1958
| Score | 2-1 to Newcastle United |
| Competition | League Division One |
| Venue | Goodison Park |
| Attendance | 22,448 |
View Everton v Newcastle United head to head
Arthur Bottom made his debut after moving from York City in January.
1 Everton
Goals:
| Eddie Thomas |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Albert Dunlop
Defender
Mick Meagan
Full back
Don Donovan
Full back
Jimmy Tansey
Centre half
Tommy Jones
Wing half
Brian Harris
Wing half
Ken Rea
Outside Left
Derek Temple
Centre forward
Dave Hickson
Forward
Jimmy Harris
Inside forward
Eddie Thomas
Goals:
| Arthur Bottom |
|
||
| Arthur Bottom |
|
Starting lineup:
Stewart Mitchell
Goalkeeper
Bill McKinney
Right back
Alf McMichael
Defender
Bob Stokoe
Centre half
Albert Franks
Wing half
Jimmy Scoular
Wing half
Bobby Mitchell
Outside Left
Arthur Bottom
Centre forward
Bill Curry
Centre forward
Alex Tait
Forward
George Eastham
Inside forward