Charlton Athletic v Newcastle United, 17 October 2004
| Score | 1-1 |
| Referee | Peter Walton |
| Competition | Premier League |
| Venue | The Valley |
| Attendance | 26,553 |
View Charlton Athletic v Newcastle United head to head
KICK-OFF: 4.05pm
Goals:
| Stephen Carr | own goal | 51 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
Dean Kiely
Defender
Hermann Hreidarsson
Defender
Luke Young
Defender/Centre back
Jonathan Fortune
Defender/Centre back
Chris Perry
Midfielder
Matt Holland
Midfielder
Danny Murphy
Midfielder
Graham Stuart
Forward
Shaun Bartlett
Forward
Kevin Lisbie
Forward
Dennis Rommedahl
Substitutions:
| Francis Jeffers for Kevin Lisbie | 79 |
Cards:
| Graham Stuart | 75 | Y |
On the bench:
Forward
Francis Jeffers
Comments:
League position: 10th Unused substitutes: Stephan Andersen, Bryan Hughes, Talal El Karkouri and Jason Euell The FA Premier League's Dubious Goals Committee ruled on the following: Charlton Athletic’s goal against Newcastle United on 17 October 2004 was in fact an own goal (Stephen Carr) and has therefore not been credited to Kevin Lisbie. [re: Circular 2 – 25/10/2004]Goals:
| Craig Bellamy | 39 |
|
Starting lineup:
Shay Given
Goalkeeper
Stephen Carr
Defender
Andy O'Brien
Defender
Robbie Elliott
Defender/Midfielder
Olivier Bernard
Defender/Left back
Darren Ambrose
Midfielder
Lee Bowyer
Midfielder
Nicky Butt
Midfielder
Jermaine Jenas
Midfielder
Craig Bellamy
Forward
Alan Shearer
Forward
Substitutions:
| Laurent Robert for Darren Ambrose | 66 |
| Shola Ameobi for Craig Bellamy | 66 |
| James Milner for Nicky Butt | 76 |
Cards:
| Shola Ameobi | 89 | Y |