Carlisle United v York City, 10 September 1957
| Score | 2-1 to Carlisle United |
| Competition | Division Three (North) |
| Attendance | 9,557 |
View Carlisle United v York City head to head
| Score | 2-1 to Carlisle United |
| Competition | Division Three (North) |
| Attendance | 9,557 |
View Carlisle United v York City head to head