AFC Wimbledon v Sutton United, 17 January 2017
| Score | 3-1 to Sutton United |
| Referee | Darren Drysdale |
| Competition | FA Cup 3rd round replay |
| Venue | Cherry Red Records Fans Stadium |
| Attendance | 4,768 |
View AFC Wimbledon v Sutton United head to head
Kick-off: 7.45pm
Goals:
| Tom Elliott | 10 |
|
Starting lineup:
Goalkeeper
James Shea
Defender
Sean Kelly
Defender/Centre back
Paul Robinson
Defender/Forward
Darius Charles
Defender/Midfielder
Barry Fuller
Midfielder
Dannie Bulman
Midfielder
Dean Parrett
Midfielder
Jake Reeves
Forward
Tom Elliott
Forward
Dominic Poleon
Forward
Lyle Taylor
Substitutions:
| Chris Robertson for Dominic Poleon | 16 |
| Chris Whelpdale for Lyle Taylor | 70 |
| Tyrone Barnett for Tom Elliott | 83 |
Cards:
| Paul Robinson | 15 | R |
| Sean Kelly | 56 | Y |
| Tyrone Barnett | 84 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Joe McDonnell
Defender
Seth Owens
Defender/Centre back
Chris Robertson
Midfielder
Alfie Egan
Midfielder
Chris Whelpdale
Forward
Tyrone Barnett
Forward
George Oakley
Goals:
| Roarie Deacon | 75 |
|
|
| Dan Fitchett | 90 |
|
|
| Max Biamou | 90 |
|
Starting lineup:
Ross Worner
Goalkeeper
Kevin Amankwaah
Defender
Dean Beckwith
Defender/Centre back
Simon Downer
Defender/Centre back
Craig Eastmond
Defender/Midfielder
Dan Spence
Defender/Midfielder
Jamie Collins
Midfielder
Bedsente Gomis
Midfielder
Roarie Deacon
Midfielder/Forward
Max Biamou
Forward
Matt Tubbs
Forward
Substitutions:
| Bradley Hudson-Odoi for Simon Downer | 66 |
| Adam May for Bedsente Gomis | 66 |
| Dan Fitchett for Matt Tubbs | 75 |
Cards:
| Roarie Deacon | 33 | Y |
| Dan Spence | 42 | Y |
| Jamie Collins | 81 | Y |
On the bench:
Goalkeeper
Wayne Shaw
Defender
Louis John
Midfielder
Nick Bailey
Midfielder
Adam May
Midfielder/Forward
Jeffrey Monakana
Forward
Dan Fitchett
Forward
Bradley Hudson-Odoi